Originally published 2016-05-27.

Low-lying reef islands in Solomon Islands sit only a short way above the sea. Photo: Javier Leon
Yes, islands really have vanished. A 2016 study in the journal Environmental Research Letters found that five small, vegetated reef islands in Solomon Islands had disappeared completely between 1947 and 2014, and six more had lost large parts of their land. None of the five lost islands was home to a village, but a nearby inhabited island, Nuatambu, saw more than half of its houses swept into the ocean.
The finding drew worldwide headlines because it was among the first studies to document, with photographs and measurements rather than stories alone, what many Pacific communities had been describing for years. It also carried a twist that headlines often missed: rising water on its own did not decide which islands survived. Waves did.
Below we explain what the researchers did, why some islands vanished while their neighbours held firm, what it meant for the people living there, and what the case tells us about the coming decades.
What the Solomon Islands study found
The research team, led by Simon Albert of the University of Queensland with colleagues including Alistair Grinham and Javier Leon, tracked the coastlines of 33 reef islands across four areas of the country: Isabel, Roviana, Choiseul and Malaita. They compared aerial photographs from 1947 with modern satellite images up to 2014, and added tree radiocarbon dating, tide-gauge records, wave models and the knowledge of local elders.
The results were stark in one place in particular. All five islands that disappeared lay in the north of Isabel Province. They ranged from roughly one to five hectares in size, and each had carried dense tropical forest, some of it centuries old. A further six islands lost a fifth or more of their area over the same period.

A bare sand patch is all that is left of one of the islands that disappeared. Photo: Simon Albert
Meanwhile, a group of islands in the calmer Roviana Lagoon, exposed to a similar rise in water level, showed little visible change in their shorelines. That contrast is the heart of the study.
Why the sea is rising faster there
Global sea level has risen around 20 centimetres since 1900, mainly because warming ocean water expands and because glaciers and ice sheets are melting. The pace is speeding up: satellites measured close to 3 millimetres a year in the 1990s and 2000s, and more than 4 millimetres a year in the decade to 2022.
Sea level is not a flat line, though. Winds, currents and natural climate cycles pile water up in some regions and draw it down in others. In the western Pacific, trade winds strengthened in the 1990s and 2000s, and Solomon Islands became a hotspot. The study reports a local rise of about 7 millimetres a year between 1994 and 2014, more than double the long-term rate of about 3 millimetres a year recorded there since 1950.
Part of that local surge is natural variability that may ease again. The researchers' point was that it offers a preview. Under all but the lowest-emission paths, much of the Pacific is expected to see similar long-term rates in the second half of this century, with natural swings stacked on top. Projections quoted in the paper put the rise in Solomon Islands at between 24 and 89 centimetres from 1996 to 2090, depending on emissions.
Why waves decided which islands survived
Earlier research on atolls in places such as Tuvalu and Kiribati had found that many reef islands are surprisingly resilient. Sand and coral rubble move around, and some islands kept their size or even grew while sea levels crept up. That work was carried out where the sea was rising at around the global average.
The Solomon Islands study added two variables at once: a faster local rise and very different exposure to ocean swell. The islands of northern Isabel face open water, and the team estimated that wave energy reaching them is about twenty times higher than in sheltered Roviana. Where higher water let larger waves break further up the beach, the shoreline retreated quickly. Where the water rose but waves stayed gentle, the islands largely held.
The authors called this a synergy between sea-level rise and waves. For anyone trying to judge which coasts are most at risk, it means that a single global number is not enough. Local wave climate, reef health and the shape of the shoreline all matter.
The people who had to move
The lost islands were uninhabited, but people on nearby coasts were already feeling the change. On Nuatambu, in Choiseul Province, around 25 families lived on an island that has since lost more than half of its habitable land. Eleven homes were washed away after 2011, according to the researchers, and families moved to the larger neighbouring island of Choiseul, though some rebuilt in places that are still exposed.

Many Solomon Islands homes stand close to the high-tide line. Photo: Simon Albert
Elsewhere, whole villages founded near the shore in the early twentieth century, often around mission stations, climbed back to inland and hilltop sites their ancestors once used. The team spoke with Sirilo Sutaroti, the 94-year-old chief of the Paurata tribe, who had led his people uphill:
“The sea has started to come inland, it forced us to move up to the hilltop and rebuild our village there away from the sea.” (Sirilo Sutaroti, quoted by the study team)
Two things stand out. First, these were not government programmes. Families paid for their own moves with very limited means. Second, customary land ownership acted as a safety net, because clans could return to land they already held. The cost was social: communities of 100 to 200 people sometimes split into scattered family hamlets.
The provincial capital, Taro, has gone further. The study notes it is set to become the first provincial capital in the world to plan the relocation of its residents and services because of rising seas.
Common misunderstandings about vanishing islands
“Five Pacific nations have been swallowed”
Some viral posts turned the study into a story about countries disappearing. The five islands were small reef islets within one country, each a few hectares in size. The finding is serious without exaggeration.
“Sea-level rise alone did it”
The authors were careful to say that wave exposure and erosion worked together with rising water. Islands in calm water with the same rise survived. That nuance is useful, not a reason for comfort, because higher seas let ordinary waves do far more damage.
“If some islands grow, there is no problem”
Atoll studies showing stable or growing islands are real, but they describe a slower rate of rise. The Solomon Islands case suggests that once the rate climbs, that natural resilience can break down, especially on exposed coasts.
What this means for adaptation
The researchers argued that planning works best when satellite data and wave models are combined with what local people already know about their coasts. Elders could date when a beach began to retreat or which sites flooded first, information no satellite archive holds.
Melchior Mataki, who chaired the country's National Disaster Council at the time, called for international support, including from the Green Climate Fund, and for scientific studies led by Solomon Islands itself. In April 2016 the country was among a group of Pacific nations that signed the Paris Agreement in New York.
A decade later, the central question from the study remains: whether climate finance actually reaches remote villages that are moving their homes uphill with their own hands. For readers far from the Pacific, the lesson is that rising seas do not arrive as one even tide. They show up first where local conditions amplify them, and the people living there are already adapting.
Sources: Albert, S. et al. (2016), Interactions between sea-level rise and wave exposure on reef island dynamics in the Solomon Islands, Environmental Research Letters; original report by the study authors in The Conversation; background from Wikipedia: Sea level rise. Photos: Javier Leon and Simon Albert.

COMMENTS