Why People Are Rude and Unkind, and Why It's Rarely About You

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Why People Are Rude and Unkind (and Why It’s Not About You)
grzz

Most rude or unkind behaviour says more about the other person's state of mind than about you. Stress, exhaustion, shame, anxiety and low mood all shorten people's fuse, and the sharp word that lands on you is often spill-over from a struggle you cannot see. That does not make rudeness acceptable, and you do not have to put up with it, but it does mean you rarely need to carry it home as proof that something is wrong with you.

The idea is often summed up in a line widely shared online and often attributed to the Brazilian novelist Paulo Coelho: “How people treat other people is a direct reflection of how they feel about themselves.” No one has traced it to one of his books, but the thought behind it is worth unpacking. Below is a personal story that shows how this works from the inside, what research says about rudeness, and practical ways to respond, whether you are on the receiving end or the one who has been snapping at others.

A story from the other side of rudeness

This piece grew out of a first-person essay on Tiny Buddha, the mindfulness site, in which the writer looked back at a period when she became the unkind one. She described herself as naturally cheerful and idealistic, the kind of person who always assumed the best about others and worried about upsetting anyone. When strangers or friends were curt with her, she used to read it as a deliberate choice, or as a sign she had done something to deserve it.

Then a spell of mild depression changed things. She cried often, pulled away from friends and lost the sense that life was bright. Her patience wore thin. In conversations she assumed people found her dull or self-absorbed, and that belief pushed her further into herself. Without ever planning to, she began to lash out, make cutting remarks and invent excuses to keep people at arm's length. The targets were mostly friends she liked.

Looking back, she saw a pattern: being prickly felt safer than risking rejection as her real self. If people disliked the harsh version of her, at least the rejection made sense. She was clear that this was no excuse, but the experience changed how she saw the rude people she met afterwards.

What research says about why people are unkind

Her story fits what clinicians see. The US National Institute of Mental Health lists irritability, frustration and increased anger among the common symptoms of depression, and notes that children and teenagers may seem irritable rather than sad. Many adults do not recognise that grumpiness can be part of a mood problem, so they and the people around them simply see a “difficult” person.

Rudeness is also contagious. In a 2015 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology, Trevor Foulk, Andrew Woolum and Amir Erez at the University of Florida followed 90 graduate students practising negotiations. Those who rated a partner as rude were more likely to be rated rude by their next partner, even a week later. In another experiment, people who merely watched a rude exchange then wrote more hostile replies to a neutral email. The researchers compared it to catching a cold: the person who snaps at you may have been snapped at an hour ago.

Other common drivers include:

  • Stress and fatigue. Tired, hungry or overloaded people have less capacity to filter what they say.
  • Insecurity and shame. Putting someone else down can be a quick, if short-lived, way to feel less small.
  • Fear of rejection. Like the essay's author, some people push others away first so they cannot be hurt.
  • Habit and upbringing. In some families, sarcasm and harsh criticism are simply how people talk.

How to stop taking rudeness personally

Knowing that rudeness usually comes from the other person's inner weather helps, but it takes practice to act on it. A few habits make it easier:

  • Pause before you respond. A breath or two gives you room to choose a reply instead of mirroring the tone, which is how incivility spreads.
  • Separate the content from the delivery. Sometimes a rude person has a fair point wrapped in a bad tone. You can take the point and leave the tone.
  • Ask a simple question. “Is everything okay?” or “Did I miss something?” often disarms people who did not realise how they sounded.
  • Set a boundary when needed. Understanding someone is not the same as tolerating mistreatment. “I'm happy to talk about this, but not like this” is a fair line.
  • Notice your own story. If a curt reply from a stranger ruins your afternoon, ask what you told yourself about it. Usually it is “they think I'm worthless”, and that is rarely what they were thinking at all.

You cannot control how anyone else behaves. You can control how much space their behaviour takes up in your head.

If you are the one who has been unkind

The essay's most useful lesson is for those of us who recognise ourselves in it. Instead of only asking why others are rude, it is worth asking why we are. What are you protecting yourself from when you snap? Who are you trying to keep away?

The writer traced her own harshness to a loop: she felt awkward, lost some friends, withdrew, and then filled the silence with cruel self-talk such as “nobody likes you”. Those thoughts did not match reality, but they shaped how she treated people. Breaking the loop started with being gentler with herself.

Some steps that help:

  • Write down the harsh thoughts. Then ask whether a friend would agree with them. Most self-critical scripts fall apart when you look at them in daylight.
  • Practise self-forgiveness. If old mistakes fuel your anger at yourself, treat them the way you would treat a loved one who made the same errors.
  • Question old labels. If you grew up being told you were “bad” or “difficult”, you are allowed to test that belief as an adult and drop it.
  • Repair when you can. A short, sincere apology to someone you snapped at rebuilds trust and makes the next outburst less likely.
  • Get support. Shifting deep patterns can take months, and many people find therapy makes it faster and easier.

When irritability might be a sign of something more

If you have felt low, empty, irritable or hopeless most of the day, nearly every day, for two weeks or more, talk to a doctor or a mental health professional. NIMH uses that two-week window when describing depression, and treatment works for many people. In the United States you can call or text 988 at any time for free, confidential support from the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Elsewhere, your doctor or a local helpline can point you to help.

Common myths about rude people

  • “Rude people just don't care.” Often they care a great deal about how they are seen, and rudeness is a clumsy defence.
  • “If someone is rude to me, I must have caused it.” You may have been the trigger, but the size of the reaction usually comes from what they were already carrying.
  • “Understanding rudeness means excusing it.” You can see the reasons and still say no to the behaviour.
  • “Kind people are never unkind.” As the essay shows, gentle people can turn sharp when they are struggling. That is a reason for compassion, including towards yourself.

The heart of it is simple: the people who are hardest to be around are often having the hardest time. Remembering that keeps you from turning someone else's bad moment into your own bad day, and it leaves room for both of you to do better next time.

Sources: Tiny Buddha: Why People Are Rude and Unkind (and Why It’s Not About You); NIMH: Depression; University of Florida: workplace rudeness is contagious; 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Photo: grzz.

Related:

COMMENTS