First published January 30, 2016.

Which parts of the United States are the most greedy, lustful or lazy? In 2009 a team of geographers from Kansas State University tried to answer that tongue-in-cheek question with real statistics. They picked a measurable stand-in for each of the seven deadly sins, gathered county-level data for roughly 3,000 US counties, and turned the results into a set of colour-coded maps.
The work was first presented at the Association of American Geographers annual meeting in Las Vegas in March 2009, starting with a study of Nevada's counties. Research associate Thomas Vought presented it, and the Las Vegas Sun summed it up nicely as “a precision party trick — rigorous mapping of ridiculous data.” The maps went viral again in later years when blogs reposted them.
Here is how each map was built, what the colours mean, and why none of this can tell you how good or bad your neighbours actually are.
How to read the colours
Each map shades counties by standard deviation from the national average for that indicator. In plain terms, darker or redder counties scored well above the typical county, and bluer ones well below it. The scale is relative: a county can look alarming simply because the national figures cluster tightly. Remember too that a large, empty western county takes up far more space on the map than a dense urban one with many more people.
The seven maps, one by one

Wrath. Measured as violent crimes reported to the FBI per person, covering murder, assault and rape. According to the Las Vegas Sun's report, high values clustered in Florida and nearby states. Reported crime depends on policing and reporting habits, so it is a proxy for violence, not for anger.

Envy. Built from property crime: robbery, burglary, larceny and car theft. The idea is that coveting other people's things sometimes ends in taking them. Places with many visitors can score high, because crimes are counted against the resident population only.

Gluttony. The number of fast food restaurants per resident. Texas reportedly stood out. Restaurant counts say more about road networks, tourism and chain strategy than about how much any individual eats.

Greed. Average income compared with the number of residents living below the poverty line, so counties with high average incomes alongside many poor residents scored as greedy. Southern Nevada stood out here, with Clark County, home of Las Vegas, ranking highest in the state.

Lust. Reported cases of sexually transmitted infections per person: HIV and AIDS, syphilis, chlamydia and gonorrhoea. This is one of the weakest proxies, because infection rates track access to testing, health services and reporting as much as behaviour.

Sloth. Spending on arts, entertainment and recreation compared with the employment rate. It is a playful definition: a county that spends heavily on leisure while fewer people work scores as slothful. Clark County, despite its casinos, came out only average.

Pride. Rather than finding a separate measure, the team averaged the other six indexes. That nods to an old idea in Christian teaching that pride is the root from which the other sins grow.
Where the seven sins come from
The list is older than the United States by more than a millennium. According to the history summarised on Wikipedia, the fourth-century monk Evagrius Ponticus described eight tempting “thoughts”, including gluttony, greed, wrath, sadness, acedia and pride. Around AD 590 Pope Gregory I reshaped the list, adding envy and treating pride as the queen of the vices. Thomas Aquinas later defended the scheme in his Summa Theologica, calling these the capital sins because other wrongs spring from them.
The familiar seven used today are pride, greed, wrath, envy, lust, gluttony and sloth. They became staples of medieval art, Dante's Purgatorio and countless sermons, which is exactly why a map labelled with them grabs attention.
What the maps cannot tell you
The biggest misunderstanding is to read these maps as a ranking of morality. They are not, and the researchers never claimed they were. A few reasons why:
- Proxies are not behaviour. A fast food outlet or a theft report is a measurable stand-in for an idea, chosen partly for fun.
- The ecological fallacy. County averages say nothing reliable about any single person in that county.
- Reporting differences. Crime and infection figures depend on how often things are reported, tested and recorded, which varies widely.
- Visitors distort per-person figures. Tourist hubs and highway towns serve many non-residents, inflating counts per local resident.
- Poverty shows up repeatedly. Several indicators are linked to income and health access, so the same disadvantaged areas can light up on multiple maps.
That last point is worth dwelling on. Labelling poorer regions as more “sinful” can reinforce stereotypes, even when the exercise is a joke. Used well, the maps are a good classroom example of how choices about data, scale and labels shape the story a map tells.
Why the project still gets shared
The sin maps endure because they mix a centuries-old moral idea with modern spatial data and a sense of humour. They show how geographers think: pick a question, find something measurable, map it, then ask whether the measure really fits. The most useful takeaway is not which county looks reddest, but the habit of reading any map's key, method and sources before trusting its headline.
Sources: Las Vegas Sun: One nation, seven sins (March 26, 2009); Wikipedia: Seven deadly sins; maps by Kansas State University geographers, as reposted by Memolition.

COMMENTS