Heather McManamy’s Farewell Letter: Humor, Love and No Regrets

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Heather McManamy’s Farewell Letter, Shared by Her Husband in 2015

Heather McManamy, a 36-year-old mother from Wisconsin, died of breast cancer on 14 December 2015. The next day her husband, Jeff, did what she had asked: he posted on her Facebook page a farewell letter she had written in advance. It opened with a joke, "The bad news is, apparently, I'm dead", and went on to thank her friends, praise her husband, and give very specific instructions about how her young daughter should be told about her death.

Within days the post had been shared more than 10,000 times and liked by over 38,000 people, and it was picked up by news outlets across the United States. Here is who Heather was, what her letter said, and why so many readers found it helpful as well as moving.

Who Heather McManamy was

Heather lived in McFarland, a village just outside Madison, and had worked as a research specialist at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. She and Jeff had been together for more than a decade, and their daughter, Brianna, was about four when Heather died.

Reports differ on exactly when her cancer was first found, but by August 2014 she had been told it was terminal. Earlier in 2015 she drew national attention for a different project: a set of cards and letters for Brianna to open at milestones Heather knew she would miss, such as a lost tooth, a first heartbreak, her wedding day and the arrival of her own first child. In the last weeks of her life she also worked on a memoir built around those cards, Cards for Brianna: A Lifetime of Lessons and Love from a Dying Mother to Her Daughter, which was scheduled for publication in spring 2016.

What her farewell letter says

Jeff introduced the post in a single line, explaining that the words were Heather's. What follows reads more like a conversation with friends than a formal goodbye.

She starts by teasing her readers for still being alive, admits that dying young is awful, and then says she feels lucky: she had a life full of love, laughter and close friends, and she claims to have no regrets. She thanks the doctors and nurses who looked after her and credits them with giving her every good day they could.

The longest passage is for Jeff. She calls him her best friend and the love of her life, says that he never backed away during the hardest parts of her illness, and describes Brianna as their love made real. She tells him she hopes that in time he will think of her and smile rather than grieve.

The letter ends with party plans. Heather asks her friends to run up a big bar tab at the funeral, to play the song "Keg on My Coffin", and to dance. She jokes that she plans to haunt each of them, so this is less a goodbye than a see-you-later, and closes with the line that became the headline in many news reports: "Don't ever forget: every day matters."

Why she asked people not to tell Brianna she was in heaven

One request stood out. Heather explained that her family was not religious and that she respected whatever beliefs comforted other people. But she asked everyone not to tell Brianna that her mother was in heaven. To a small child, she reasoned, that would sound as if Mom had chosen to go somewhere else, when in fact she had fought to stay as long as she could.

Instead she wanted Brianna to hear that her mother's love, energy and memories were still with her, and to be told lots of stories, preferably ones that made Heather sound much cooler than she really was.

Her instinct matches common advice to parents. KidsHealth, a children's health resource from Nemours, recommends using clear and direct words when telling a child about a death, sharing your family's own beliefs about what happens afterwards, and continuing to talk about the person who died. Drawing pictures and telling stories are suggested as ways to help children remember someone with love.

Why she rejected the language of battle

Heather also objected to a phrase that appears in countless obituaries. She did not want anyone to say she had lost a fight with cancer. In her view, cancer had taken her health but never her love, hope or happiness, and living well for years with the illness was itself a win. In her own words: "I didn't lose, dammit."

Many patients share that discomfort. Describing illness as a war can make people feel that dying means they did not try hard enough, when survival often depends on the type of cancer, its stage and plain luck. Heather described her experience as life, sometimes random and unfair, rather than a contest she failed.

The "physicist's eulogy" she mentions

Near the end of the letter Heather tells Jeff to look up a piece known as the physicist's eulogy. It was written by the Chicago comedian and commentator Aaron Freeman and broadcast on NPR in 2005. Freeman imagines a physicist explaining at a funeral that energy is never created or destroyed, so the energy that made up the person who died has not vanished, only spread out.

For a non-religious family, the idea offered a way to tell her family she was still with them that fit what Heather actually believed. She even added that she would stay close in the least creepy way possible.

What readers can take from it

  • Say the important things while you can. Heather's cards and letter gave her family words to hold on to. Some people facing serious illness write legacy letters, record videos or make memory boxes for their children.
  • Tell people what you want. Her wishes on religion, language and even the funeral music spared her family guesswork at a painful time.
  • Keep the person's voice alive. Her request for stories, including the exaggerated ones, is a reminder that children benefit from hearing about a parent's personality, not only their illness.
  • Get checked if something seems wrong. Breast cancer can affect younger women too. If you notice a change in your breasts or have questions about screening, talk to a doctor.

Heather's letter is still remembered because it refused to be only sad. It is funny, frank and full of gratitude, and it asks the people she left behind to notice how fragile and precious an ordinary day is.

Sources: Heather McManamy's letter on Facebook; NBC; Fox News; FOX 32 Chicago; Futurism on Aaron Freeman's eulogy; KidsHealth: helping your child deal with death.

Related:

COMMENTS