Healthy Strangers and Young Cancer Patients Asked the Same Question

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Healthy Volunteers and Young Cancer Patients Answer the Same Wish

In this short Spanish film, two groups of people sit on either side of a screen and answer the same two questions: "If you could have one wish, what would it be?" and "What makes you happy?" The people on one side are healthy volunteers. The people on the other side, whom the volunteers cannot see, are teenagers and young adults with cancer, or their relatives. The healthy group answer first, with wishes about travel, jobs and careers. Then they hear what the other side wishes for, and the mood in the room changes completely.

The video was made by Barcelona photographer and art director Paola Calasanz and her studio, Dulcinea Estudios, for a Spanish association that supports adolescents and young adults with cancer. It was posted on YouTube in January 2015 and spread worldwide that summer.

Watch the experiment

The film is in Spanish with subtitles in many shared versions. It runs only a few minutes, and most of its force comes from the editing: each healthy participant's answer is followed by the answer of the person behind the screen, so the contrast lands immediately.

How the video was made

According to an interview Calasanz gave to the Chilean outlet El Ciudadano, the healthy participants answered a Facebook advertisement looking for people to appear in a viral video about life. They were told that they were part of one social group and that the people on the other side belonged to a different group, but not that those people were ill. Nobody was paid to take part, she said.

The volunteers were asked to be realistic and avoid stock answers such as world peace. Their wishes were the kind most of us would give: to travel, to land a job in New York, to start a company, to pass a competitive civil-service exam. None of these are selfish or shallow. They are ordinary hopes from people who can take tomorrow for granted.

The young people on the other side answered from a very different place. El Ciudadano's writer noted that most viewers could guess the kind of wishes that come from people in the middle of cancer treatment, and the video relies on that: what matters is how the healthy side reacts when they hear them. Many of the healthy participants ended up in tears. Calasanz was open about the design: she said the format was built to create contrast, and that the editing does a great deal of the work.

Who the young people behind the screen are

Doctors and researchers often group patients aged roughly 15 to 39 as adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with cancer. The US National Cancer Institute estimates that about 85,000 people in this age group were diagnosed in the United States in 2025, around 4 percent of all cancer diagnoses. The most common types include breast, thyroid and testicular cancer and melanoma, along with leukaemias, lymphomas, sarcomas and brain tumours.

Overall survival for this group has been improving and is now high for many cancer types, though it varies widely between diagnoses. What sets AYAs apart is timing. Cancer arrives just as people are finishing school, starting jobs, moving out or thinking about families. Treatment can affect fertility, interrupt studies and careers, and leave young patients feeling isolated from friends whose lives keep moving forward. That is why associations like the one that commissioned this video focus on peer support, emotional care and helping young people keep a sense of normal life.

Seen in that light, the answers behind the screen are not only moving. They point to what illness takes from young patients first: ordinary days, unbroken time with the people they love, and the freedom to plan.

Why the contrast affects viewers so strongly

Psychologists call the ability to see a situation from someone else's point of view perspective-taking. Most of the time we do it poorly, because our own concerns fill the frame. The screen in this film removes the usual cues, such as appearance, age and setting, and leaves only words. When the volunteers hear those words without warning, they are forced into another person's perspective for a moment, and so are we as viewers.

There is also a well-studied link between noticing what we already have and feeling better day to day. Research on gratitude, including studies in which people wrote down a few things they were thankful for each day, has found modest improvements in reported happiness and mood, although much of the evidence comes from small or narrow samples. The film does not prove anything scientifically, but it captures the same idea in a few minutes: appreciation often arrives by comparison.

A fair criticism, and a better takeaway

Not everyone loved the video. Some viewers felt it set healthy participants up to look selfish, when their wishes were perfectly reasonable. Calasanz responded to that criticism herself, pointing out that the contrast came from the structure and editing rather than from any judgement of the volunteers. It is worth keeping in mind. Wanting a job, a trip or a business of your own is not a moral failing, and young cancer patients often share those same ambitions once treatment is over.

The more useful lesson is not guilt but attention. A few practical ways to carry it forward:

  • Notice the ordinary. A walk, a shared meal or an uneventful afternoon with family can look very different to someone whose days are shaped by hospital visits. They are easy to overlook when they are always there.
  • Say it out loud. Telling people what they mean to you costs nothing and is one of the things people most regret leaving unsaid.
  • Support young patients in practical ways. Hospitals and charities for teenagers and young adults with cancer often need volunteers, donations or simply friends who keep inviting a patient along, even when the answer is often "not today".
  • Consider blood and stem cell donation. Many cancer treatments depend on donated blood products, and young adults with leukaemia or lymphoma may need a stem cell donor. Your national blood or bone marrow service can explain whether you are eligible.

For another piece of filmed human connection that moved millions of viewers, see Marina Abramović and Ulay Meet During The Artist Is Present.

Sources: Video by Paola Calasanz / Dulcinea Estudios for the Asociación de Adolescentes y Adultos Jóvenes con Cáncer. El Ciudadano, 9 August 2015 (interview with Paola Calasanz); National Cancer Institute: Adolescents and Young Adults with Cancer; Wikipedia: Gratitude; earlier coverage by AmazingOasis.

Related:

COMMENTS