Six Lies Low Self-Esteem Tells You and How to Question Them

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2015-06-16.

Six Unhelpful Thought Patterns and Ways to Question Them

Low self-esteem has a voice, and it is very persuasive. It tells you that other people are simply better, that you cannot cope alone, that life is rigged, that trying is pointless, that it is too late, or that you are useless. These thoughts feel like facts, but they are better described as habits of thinking. Psychologists call many of them cognitive distortions, and the good news is that they can be noticed, questioned and gradually replaced with something more accurate.

Below are six of the most common, why they are misleading, and a practical way to challenge each one.

Why the mind tells us unhelpful stories

In the 1960s and 1970s the psychiatrist Aaron Beck noticed that his depressed patients had "automatic thoughts": quick, negative interpretations that popped up unbidden and coloured how they felt. His student David Burns later popularised a list of these patterns in the 1980 book Feeling Good. They include all-or-nothing thinking, overgeneralising from one event, filtering out the positive, fortune-telling, labelling yourself, and treating a feeling as proof.

These patterns are not signs of weakness. Everyone uses them sometimes, particularly under stress. They become a problem when they run unchecked and start making decisions for us, such as skipping the interview or not sending the message.

Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), which grew out of Beck's work, teaches people to catch these thoughts and test them. The aim is not forced positivity. It is accuracy.

Thought 1: "Everyone else is better than me"

This is a classic case of comparing your inside to everyone else's outside. You know every doubt you have; you see only other people's polished results. It leads to self-sabotage: a person convinced that a hundred stronger candidates have applied may not bother applying at all.

It is also worth being honest: people do not all start with the same chances. Background, health, money and luck all play a part. But that cuts both ways. Others are not uniformly ahead of you, and the outcome of any single application, audition or conversation is genuinely uncertain. Effort, preparation and showing up change the odds more than most people expect.

Try asking: "What is the actual evidence that I would lose? What would I tell a friend in my position?"

Thought 2: "I can't live without my partner"

Deep attachment to a partner is normal and healthy. The distortion is the belief that your worth or survival depends entirely on one person. When that belief drives a relationship, it can lead to clinging, jealousy, fear of conflict and staying in situations that are not good for you.

People who can be reasonably content on their own tend to choose partners more freely and bring more to a relationship. Building a life with your own friendships, interests and goals is not a threat to love. It makes a stable partnership more likely.

Try asking: "Which parts of my life feel like mine alone? What would I like to build that does not depend on anyone else?"

Thoughts 3 and 4: "Life is unfair" and "Why even try?"

"Life is sad and unfair"

Some things in life genuinely are unfair: illness, loss, discrimination, accidents. Pretending otherwise does not help. The distortion lies in the overgeneralisation: "Bad things always happen to me, so nothing I do matters." That conclusion quietly hands all control to fate and makes it easy to ignore the choices that are still open.

A balanced view holds both truths. Some outcomes are beyond your control, and your responses, habits and relationships still shape a great deal of your life.

"There's no point in trying"

This thought protects us from the pain of failing, but at a steep price. If you never try, failure is guaranteed. Setbacks are a normal part of any worthwhile goal; if goals were easy, they would just be tasks.

The playwright Samuel Beckett wrote a line in his 1983 prose work Worstward Ho that is now quoted everywhere: "Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." In context it is far bleaker than a motivational poster suggests, but the popular reading still holds: improvement usually comes through repeated, imperfect attempts.

Try asking: "What is one small, low-risk attempt I could make this week?"

Thought 5: "It's too late for me"

This is fortune-telling: predicting the future as if it were already written. People change careers, return to education, learn instruments, start businesses and find new partners at every age. Some doors do close with time, and it is fine to grieve them. Far more remain open than the "too late" voice admits.

Try asking: "Is it really too late, or does it just feel uncomfortable to be a beginner?" Then look for one person who started the same thing later than you.

Thought 6: "I'm useless"

Labelling yourself with a single word after a bad day or a mistake is one of the most damaging distortions, because it turns an event into an identity. "I made an error at work" becomes "I am useless", and that label then colours everything else.

Nobody is useless. People have different strengths, and many of yours may be invisible to you because they come naturally. Ask people who know you what they rely on you for; the answers are often surprising.

Research on self-compassion suggests that treating yourself with the same kindness you would offer a friend is linked with lower anxiety and depression and with healthier motivation, not with laziness.

A simple exercise to test any of these thoughts

  1. Write the thought down word for word, along with the situation that triggered it.
  2. Rate how strongly you believe it, from 0 to 100.
  3. List the evidence for it and, separately, the evidence against it or details that complicate it.
  4. Write a more balanced version. Not "I'm amazing", but something like "I struggled with that task, and I have handled similar ones before."
  5. Re-rate the original thought. Even a drop from 90 to 60 is progress.

Practised regularly, this kind of thought record is one of the core tools of CBT. Self-help can go a long way, but if low mood, hopelessness or self-criticism persist for weeks or start to affect daily life, please talk to a doctor or a mental health professional. Effective help is available.

Sources: Wikipedia: Cognitive distortion; Wikipedia: Self-compassion; Wikipedia: Worstward Ho; NIMH: Depression.

COMMENTS