How Writing Affects Your Brain: What the Science Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
0 0 Edit this post
Writing and the Brain: Questions Behind an Infographic

Writing is one of the most demanding things the brain does. Turning a thought into words on a page draws on language areas, memory, planning, fine motor control and vision all at once. Research does show some real effects: putting thoughts into words can help you organise and remember them, writing about difficult experiences can help some people feel better, and handwriting engages the brain differently from typing. But several popular claims, including some in the well-known infographic below, go further than the evidence.

Most of us write something every day, even if it is only a shopping list or a quick message. Here is what that everyday act involves, which claims hold up, and how to use writing to think and remember better.

Which parts of the brain are involved when you write

No single "writing centre" exists. Writing borrows from systems that evolved for speech, movement and vision:

  • Frontal lobe. Planning what to say, choosing words and organising sentences lean heavily on the frontal lobe, which also handles reasoning, judgement and voluntary movement. Broca's area, in the left frontal lobe for most people, is closely tied to producing language.
  • Temporal lobe. Wernicke's area, near the junction of the temporal and parietal lobes, is linked to understanding language and finding the meaning of words.
  • Parietal lobe. This region helps connect letters, sounds and spatial information. Damage here can produce agraphia, a loss of the ability to write or spell, which neurologists have documented for more than a century.
  • Motor areas and the cerebellum. Forming letters by hand or hitting keys needs precise, practised movement.
  • Visual areas. You read your own words as you go, and that feedback lets you correct and revise.

The infographic below sketches this map in a friendly way. Its anatomy is broadly right; it is some of the "fun facts" further down that need a closer look.

How does the act of writing affect your brain

Does writing things down help you remember?

Usually, yes, though not for the reason the infographic gives. It credits the reticular activating system, a network in the brainstem, with "filtering" information and flagging what you write as important. The reticular formation is real, but its best-established job is controlling arousal and wakefulness, the difference between being alert and being asleep. There is no good evidence that the physical act of writing switches it on in a special way. That explanation is popular in self-help books rather than neuroscience.

The better explanation is simpler. To write something down you have to pay attention to it, decide what matters and put it into your own words. Psychologists call this kind of active processing "generation", and it reliably improves memory compared with passively reading or hearing information. A written note also gives you something to review later, which is one of the most effective ways to learn anything.

Handwriting versus typing

A widely reported study from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology, published in Frontiers in Psychology in 2024 by Audrey van der Weel and Ruud van der Meer, recorded brain activity with high-density EEG while students wrote words by hand or typed them. Handwriting was associated with more widespread connectivity between brain regions, and the authors argued this supports teaching handwriting in schools.

Other researchers urged caution. In a published commentary, Svetlana Pinet and Marieke Longcamp pointed out that the study did not measure learning at all, that the typing condition was unusual (participants typed with one finger and could not see their text), and that more brain connectivity may simply reflect the extra effort of slower handwriting. Their view was not that handwriting is unimportant, only that claims about better learning still need direct tests.

A sensible reading of the evidence: handwriting is worth keeping, especially for young children learning letters and for jotting notes you want to think through. Typing is faster and easier to edit. The habit that helps most with either is summarising in your own words instead of copying word for word.

Why stories stick better than bullet points

The infographic's middle section argues that stories engage far more of the brain than a list of facts. There is solid research behind part of this. In a 2010 study at Princeton University, published in PNAS, Greg Stephens, Lauren Silbert and Uri Hasson used fMRI to record a woman telling an unrehearsed real-life story and then recorded 11 people listening to it. The listeners' brain activity tracked the speaker's, usually a second or few behind, and the closer the coupling, the better the listeners understood the story. When they heard a story in a language they did not speak, the coupling disappeared.

The idea that action words light up motor areas, and that sensory descriptions engage sensory areas, also has experimental support, although effects in brain scans are subtle and do not mean the reader "experiences" the scene as if it were real. The practical lesson for writers holds up anyway: concrete detail, people and events are easier to follow and remember than abstractions.

Clichés and the brain: a claim that got reversed

The infographic says Spanish researchers found that familiar figures of speech such as "a rough day" no longer register as sensory and are processed as plain words. The research appears to have been garbled in retelling. Spanish researchers did find that words with strong smell associations, such as "cinnamon", activated smell-related brain regions. But the study usually cited on texture metaphors, by Simon Lacey, Randall Stilla and K. Sathian at Emory University in 2012, found the opposite of what the infographic states: metaphors like "a rough day" did activate a texture-sensitive area of the brain.

Clichés are still worth avoiding, just for a different reason. Readers skim over phrases they have seen a thousand times, and fresh, specific wording does a better job of holding attention.

Writing, stress and mood

The claim that writing can calm the mind has the strongest research tradition of all. In the 1980s the psychologist James Pennebaker developed "expressive writing": people write about a difficult experience and their deepest feelings for around 15 minutes a day over four days, while a comparison group writes about neutral topics. In early studies the expressive writers made fewer doctor visits in the following months, and later work reported benefits for mood and some stress-related symptoms.

The results are not uniform. Some trials and reviews have found small or no effects, and people often feel worse for a short time after writing about painful events. Expressive writing is a low-cost tool that helps some people; it is not a treatment for depression or trauma. Anyone struggling should talk to a doctor or mental health professional.

The "other facts", checked

  • "97% of people write their own name when trying a new pen." This circulates widely, but we could not trace it to a published study. Treat it as trivia, not data.
  • "Books contain 50% more rare words than prime-time TV." The idea comes from research counting uncommon words in different kinds of text, which found that books, even children's books, use more rare words than television dialogue. The exact percentage depends on what is compared, so the specific figure is best treated as approximate.
  • "UK teenagers have a reading age of 10 or 11." The infographic gives no source, and we could not confirm which study it means. Reports of this kind have often measured the difficulty of the books pupils choose rather than what they are able to read, which is not the same thing, so the figure is best treated as unconfirmed.
  • "Writing works like meditation." Partly supported, as the expressive-writing research shows, though results vary from person to person.

How to use writing to think and remember better

  • After reading or listening to something, close the source and write a short summary from memory.
  • Take notes in your own words rather than transcribing.
  • Keep a notebook or file for ideas; writing a half-formed thought down often shows you where it is weak.
  • Try a few days of reflective writing when something is weighing on you, and stop if it makes things worse.
  • When you write for others, use concrete examples and stories, and replace tired phrases with specific ones.

Sources: Infographic by Daily Infographic, via Memolition; Wikipedia: Reticular formation; Stephens, Silbert and Hasson, "Speaker–listener neural coupling underlies successful communication", PNAS 2010; Pinet and Longcamp, commentary on van der Weel and van der Meer (2024), Frontiers in Psychology; Wikipedia: Expressive writing.

Related:

Labels:

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

COMMENTS

BLOGGER