The Five Monkeys Experiment: A Parable, Not a Real Study

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

The "five monkeys experiment" is one of the most shared stories about conformity: scientists put five monkeys in a cage with a ladder and bananas, soak the whole group with cold water whenever one climbs, and end up with a group that beats any climber even after every original monkey has been replaced. It is a memorable parable, but no published study ever did this. The closest real research, from the 1960s, is far smaller and its results are more interesting than the legend.

The Experiment - A group of scientists placed 5 monkeys in a cage and in the middle, a ladder with bananas on top. Every time a monkey went up the ladder, the scientists soaked the rest of the monkeys with cold water.
The Experiment - The results may surprise you.

The poster above tells the full version of the story and ends with the classic punchline: if you could ask the last monkeys why they attack climbers, they would say that is simply how things are done around here. It then asks readers to share it and to "evolve".

Credits: Image via Web Fail, shared by Why don't you try this.

The story in brief

In the usual telling, five monkeys share a cage. A bunch of bananas hangs at the top of a ladder. Each time a monkey starts to climb, the researchers spray all the others with cold water. Soon the monkeys attack anyone who goes near the ladder, and the spraying stops. One monkey is then swapped for a newcomer, who heads for the bananas and is beaten. The swaps continue until none of the monkeys in the cage has ever been sprayed, yet the beatings go on.

The moral is aimed at people, not primates. Offices, schools and families keep rules long after the reason for them has disappeared, and newcomers learn to enforce them without asking why.

Is it a real experiment?

No. Researchers and writers who have tried to trace it have found no paper describing five monkeys, a ladder, bananas and cold-water punishment. The story spread widely after it appeared as an anecdote in Competing for the Future (1994), the management bestseller by Gary Hamel and C. K. Prahalad, where it served to illustrate corporate inertia rather than to report a finding.

Copies of this image have circulated with a credit linking it to Harry Harlow and his colleagues at the University of Wisconsin. That attribution does not hold up. Harlow is famous for very different, and much criticised, work on rhesus monkeys: infants raised with wire and cloth "surrogate mothers", and studies of maternal separation and social isolation. None of his described experiments involve ladders, bananas or cold showers.

The real study behind the legend

The nearest genuine research is a chapter by primatologist G. R. Stephenson, "Cultural acquisition of a specific learned response among rhesus monkeys", published in the edited volume Progress in Primatology (Stuttgart, 1967; some sources give 1966). Stephenson trained rhesus monkeys to avoid touching an object by punishing contact with a blast of air. When a trained monkey was paired with an untrained one, it sometimes stopped the newcomer from approaching the object, so the avoidance was passed on.

The details matter, though. The study used pairs, not a group of five, and the effect was not universal. Writers who have summarised the chapter note that under some conditions the influence ran the other way, with naive newcomers leading the trained monkeys to lose their fear. In other words, the real research supports the idea that habits can be socially transmitted, but not the tidy, inevitable outcome of the parable.

What researchers do know about copying behaviour

Social learning in primates is well documented. Young monkeys and apes learn what to eat, what to fear and how to use tools largely by watching others, and studies of wild groups have recorded local traditions that differ from one population to the next. Humans are even stronger imitators: children tend to copy every step an adult shows them, including steps that are obviously unnecessary, a tendency psychologists call over-imitation.

So the instinct behind the story is reasonable. Groups do keep traditions whose original purpose has been forgotten. The mistake is presenting a made-up scene as a laboratory result.

How to use the parable honestly

  • Call it a parable. It still works as a teaching story, as long as nobody claims scientists proved it.
  • Ask why a rule exists. The useful lesson is to check whether the original reason still applies before defending or dropping it.
  • Remember the newcomers. In the real study, fresh members could also change the group. New people who ask awkward questions are often how organisations improve.
  • Check viral "science" stories. If a famous experiment has no named authors, journal or year, treat it with caution.

The five monkeys never existed, but the question they raise is a good one: how many of our own ladders are we still guarding for no reason?

Sources: David Wees: the five monkeys parable and Stephenson (1967); Xebia: The legend of the 5 monkeys; Wikipedia: Harry Harlow; Wikipedia: C. K. Prahalad.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 4
  1. While the findings of this experiment are interesting, I don't think we should abuse monkeys to prove people are stupid.

    ReplyDelete
  2. See, that's what behind the use of water cannon and riot police when people are asking for more democracy...

    ReplyDelete
  3. thats an awful lot of spanking the monkey......

    ReplyDelete
  4. The evolution is just the scientific concept of the world. bkexperience.xyz
    mykrogerfeedback.xyz

    ReplyDelete