Edward Snowden at SXSW 2014: Encryption, Oversight and Surveillance

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

On 10 March 2014, Edward Snowden made his first live appearance before a large American audience. Speaking by video from Russia to the SXSW Interactive festival in Austin, Texas, the former National Security Agency contractor argued that mass surveillance was harming the internet and that everyday encryption was still one of the most effective defences against it. He also said that, given the choice again, he would still have leaked the documents.

Edward Snowden’s 2014 SXSW Conversation About Surveillance

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)



Who Snowden is and why the talk mattered

Snowden worked as a contractor for the NSA. In May 2013 he left the United States for Hong Kong, and from 5 June 2013 newspapers led by The Guardian began publishing stories based on classified documents he had given to journalists including Glenn Greenwald and Laura Poitras. The Guardian revealed his identity on 9 June at his request.

US prosecutors charged him in June 2013. He landed at Moscow’s Sheremetyevo Airport on 23 June with a revoked passport and spent 39 days in the transit area before Russia granted him temporary asylum on 1 August 2013.

By March 2014 he had given few public talks. SXSW, a festival full of developers, designers and start-up founders, was a deliberate choice: he wanted to speak to the people who build the technology rather than to politicians.

How the session worked

The conversation was organised with the American Civil Liberties Union. Ben Wizner, director of the ACLU’s Speech, Privacy and Technology Project and Snowden’s legal adviser, moderated. Christopher Soghoian, the ACLU’s principal technologist, joined the discussion. The Texas Tribune streamed it live.

Snowden appeared through a Google Hangout on Air, relayed through proxy servers to hide his location (Computerworld reported seven). Computerworld pointed out the irony of using a Google service for a talk about surveillance.

Not everyone welcomed the invitation. Representative Mike Pompeo of Kansas wrote to the organisers asking them to withdraw it and said Snowden gave real whistleblowers a bad name. SXSW kept the session.

What Snowden said

His central message was about scale. Agencies can always target a specific person if they want to, he argued, but indiscriminate collection works only because so much of what we send is unprotected. If ordinary communication were encrypted end to end, collecting everything would become far too expensive, and spies would have to focus on genuine suspects. As Computerworld summarised his point, hacking a device is possible, but it does not scale to whole populations.

He called encryption a “defense against the dark arts” of the digital age, and told the audience that mass surveillance was “setting fire to the future of the Internet”, casting the developers in the room as the people who could put it out.

On the question that gave this post its original headline, Fox News quoted him saying: “I took an oath to support and defend the Constitution, and I saw that the Constitution was violated on a massive scale.”

He also criticised oversight. Congress, he said, had failed to challenge testimony by Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, which Snowden described as untrue, and the secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court approved requests without public scrutiny.

The practical advice he gave in 2014

For individuals, Snowden and Soghoian suggested a short list of tools available at the time:

  • full-disk encryption on computers and phones;
  • encrypted connections (SSL, today usually called TLS, the “https” in a web address);
  • browser add-ons that block scripts and trackers, such as NoScript and Ghostery;
  • the Tor network for anonymous browsing.

Soghoian added that, in his view, Firefox was better for privacy and Chrome better for security, and that end-to-end encryption sits uneasily with business models built on advertising. Treat this as a record of 2014 advice rather than a current security guide: tools, defaults and threats have changed a great deal since then.

What happened next

The debate Snowden started did change the law. On 2 June 2015, President Barack Obama signed the USA FREEDOM Act, which was introduced after the 2013 disclosures and was meant to end the NSA’s bulk collection of Americans’ phone records under Section 215 of the Patriot Act. The government now has to name a specific person, account or address when requesting records. Critics argued that it left other surveillance powers, such as Section 702, untouched.

Snowden himself stayed in Russia. He received permanent residency in October 2020 and Russian citizenship on 26 September 2022. Whether he is seen as a whistleblower or a lawbreaker still depends very much on who you ask, and the SXSW talk is a useful snapshot of how he made his case at the height of the controversy.

Why the talk still reads well today

Much of what he urged in Austin has since become normal. Encrypted web connections are standard, and many popular messaging apps encrypt messages end to end by default. The bigger question he raised, who may collect information about us, under what authority and with what oversight, is still argued over in parliaments and courts around the world.

Sources: Wikipedia: Edward Snowden; ACLU; Computerworld; Scientific American; Fox News; Wikipedia: USA Freedom Act.

Related:

COMMENTS