
The short answer
There is no good evidence that women, as a group, need more sleep than men because their brains are "more complex" or because they multitask. Some studies find that women sleep a little longer or spend more time in bed, and many find that women report more sleep problems. But the popular "20 extra minutes" figure is not the result of a study. It is a loose estimate from one British sleep scientist, and even he later said he had been misquoted.
The official advice from sleep medicine is the same for every adult: aim for at least seven hours a night, and pay attention to how rested you actually feel.
Where the "20 minutes" claim came from
The story has circulated since about 2008 and resurfaces every few years, often around the holidays. Versions shared by sites such as Higher Perspective in 2015 and Healthy Food House in 2016 told couples that the wife should be the one sleeping in, because her busy brain needs extra recovery time.
Most of the quotes in those posts came from a 2010 Daily Mail feature built around Professor Jim Horne, then head of the Sleep Research Centre at Loughborough University and author of Sleepfaring. His idea was simple: deep sleep lets the cortex recover, so a brain that works harder during the day might need a bit more of it. He suggested that because women tend to juggle more tasks, they might use more of the cortex and need slightly more deep sleep, about 20 minutes on average.
The viral articles turned that speculation into "research says." They also mixed in a quote from a different scientist and presented the whole package as if it came from one new study.
What the researcher actually said
When the fact-checking site Snopes looked into the story in December 2016, it concluded that the viral version did not reflect the science or the views of the scientist it quoted. Horne himself had distanced himself from the headline: "I never said that women actually need more sleep, they just tend to take more sleep."
That is an important difference. Observing that a group sleeps longer does not prove that it needs to. People sleep longer for many reasons, including opportunity, habits, health conditions, caring duties and how sleep is measured.
Horne did repeat the multitasking idea in his 2016 book Sleeplessness, but the theory depends on a premise that has not held up well: that women are reliably better multitaskers. Several studies cited by Snopes, including work published in Applied Cognitive Psychology and Psychological Science, found no clear female advantage, or only an advantage on certain kinds of task.
What studies show about men, women and sleep
Sex differences in sleep are real, but they are smaller and more complicated than the headline suggests:
- Duration: A study of about 400 British adults who logged their sleep over 15 nights found that women tended to sleep somewhat longer than men. A larger British survey of around 2,000 adults found men and women slept about the same amount. Reviews of sleep epidemiology report that women sleep a little longer mainly in young and middle adulthood.
- Time in bed versus sleep: One 2014 study found women spent about 15 minutes longer in bed than men but actually slept about 11 minutes less, which points to more broken or lighter sleep rather than a greater need.
- Sleep problems: Women are more likely to report insomnia and poor sleep, and conditions such as pregnancy, menopause and some chronic pain disorders add to that.
- Consequences of poor sleep: A 2008 study at Duke University, led by psychologist Edward Suarez, measured sleep, mood and blood markers linked to heart disease and diabetes. Poor sleep was tied to more distress and higher risk markers in both sexes, but the links were significantly stronger in women. That is a finding about harm from bad sleep, not about the amount of sleep anyone needs.
Put together, the research suggests women may be more affected by poor sleep and more likely to struggle to get good sleep. It does not show that a female brain requires a fixed bonus of sleep each night.
How much sleep adults really need
In 2015 the American Academy of Sleep Medicine and the Sleep Research Society asked 15 experts to review thousands of studies on sleep and health. Their consensus applies to all adults: "Adults should sleep 7 or more hours per night on a regular basis to promote optimal health."
The same groups stress that individual needs vary. Some healthy adults genuinely need more than nine hours, and a small minority are natural short sleepers who feel fine on less than six. Quality and regularity matter too: seven hours of broken sleep at random times is not the same as seven steady hours.
A practical test is how you feel during the day. If you need an alarm every morning, sleep much longer on weekends, or struggle to stay alert in the afternoon, you are probably not getting enough, whatever your sex.
Practical tips for couples and anyone short on sleep
- Track a normal week. Note when you fall asleep and wake without an alarm on holidays; that is a fair guide to your own need.
- Share the load. Late-night childcare and household tasks often fall unevenly. Taking turns with night duties helps both partners more than arguing about who deserves a lie-in.
- Keep a steady schedule. Going to bed and getting up at similar times every day supports deeper, more efficient sleep.
- Mind the bedroom. A cool, dark, quiet room and a break from screens before bed make it easier to fall and stay asleep.
- Take persistent problems seriously. Long-term insomnia, loud snoring, gasping at night or extreme daytime sleepiness can signal treatable conditions. Talk to a doctor if they last more than a few weeks.
Myths worth retiring
"Women's brains are more complex, so they need more rest." Male and female brains differ in some ways on average, but "more complex" is not a scientific measure, and no study has linked it to sleep need.
"A study found women need exactly 20 minutes more." No such study exists; the number was an informal estimate.
"Men can get by on less." The seven-hour minimum applies to everyone. Short sleep raises health risks for men too.
The kinder takeaway for any household is simple: whoever is tired should get the chance to sleep, and both partners deserve enough of it.
Sources: Snopes: Do women need more sleep than men because their brains work harder? (December 2016); American Academy of Sleep Medicine, Sleep Education: 7 and Up. The viral claim circulated via Higher Perspective, based on quotes from a 2010 Daily Mail interview with Jim Horne.
Related:- 6 Diseases Your Lack Of Sleep Could Be Causing
- Your Ancestors Didn’t Sleep Like You – Are We Doing It Wrong?
- A Sleep-Deprivation Infographic: Reading the Claims Carefully
- Here's What Happens To Your Brain When You Nap
- Napping can Dramatically Increase Learning, Memory, Awareness, and More
- Alternative Sleep Cycles: 7-10 Hours Are Not Needed
- Eight Sleeping Positions and the Limits of General Health Claims
- 13 Common Symbols In Dreams & What They Mean
- Astral Projection 101: DMT & Sleep Paralysis
- Lingvistov's Sleep-Lover Comics Turn Bedtime Into a Joke

COMMENTS