Carolyn Hartz at 70: Her Sugar-Free Diet and What Science Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

Carolyn Hartz, an Australian businesswoman, became an internet talking point in 2017 when photos of her on the beach at almost 70 went around the world. Her explanation was simple: she gave up added sugar about 28 years earlier, after being told she was pre-diabetic, and built her routine around protein at every meal, regular exercise, good sleep and a calm, grateful outlook.

Her story is inspiring, but it also raises fair questions. Can cutting sugar really keep someone looking decades younger? What does the evidence say, and what can the rest of us sensibly take from her habits? Here is her story, followed by what reliable health bodies say about sugar and ageing.

Who Carolyn Hartz is

Hartz is a mother and grandmother who runs SweetLife, an Australian business that imports and sells xylitol, a sugar substitute, along with sugar-free baking products. She has said the company grew out of her own need to find sweet foods she could eat without sugar.

She first spoke about her lifestyle to Australian media, including News.com.au and Daily Mail Australia. The pictures that went viral showed her in swimwear on the sand and in the surf, and the reaction was instant. Many people refused to believe she was close to 70. She later appeared on television programmes abroad, including ITV's This Morning in the UK.

70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

Why she gave up sugar

By her own account, Hartz was once a self-confessed sugar addict. The turning point came in her early forties, when a doctor told her she was pre-diabetic. Prediabetes means blood sugar is higher than normal but not yet high enough for a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes. It is far more common than most people realise: the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that more than two in five American adults have it, and many do not know.

The good news is that prediabetes can often be turned around. The CDC says structured lifestyle programmes can roughly halve the risk of developing type 2 diabetes, through modest weight loss and around 150 minutes of brisk activity a week. Hartz chose a stricter route than most: she cut out added sugar entirely.

She has admitted it was hard at first and that she still gets cravings. Her main defence against them is protein. She makes sure every meal includes some, especially breakfast, because she finds it keeps her full and steadies her appetite for sweets.

70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

Her daily habits, one by one

Sugar gets the headlines, but Hartz describes a whole routine rather than a single trick. These are the habits she has talked about in interviews:

  • No added sugar. She sweetens tea and home baking with xylitol and makes treats with ingredients such as almond meal and coconut. She has also mentioned enjoying a few squares of dark chocolate.
  • Protein with every meal. Eggs, fish, meat, dairy or legumes help keep hunger in check between meals.
  • Mindful eating. She pays attention to both what she eats and how much. Her advice to customers is to slow down and actually taste each mouthful, which makes overeating less likely.
  • Regular movement. She keeps to an exercise routine and took up yoga in her mid-sixties.
  • Eight hours of sleep. She has said she aims for a full night every night.
  • A simple, consistent skincare routine that she says she has followed since her teens.
  • Meditation and gratitude. She treats each day as a gift and believes her attitude matters almost as much as her diet.
70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

Hartz is also open about the fact that staying in shape gets harder with age. Her view is that a slowing metabolism is not a reason to give up, only a reason to make more deliberate choices.

"We know our metabolism slows down as we get older; it just means we have to take control and make healthier choices."
Carolyn Hartz, speaking to Australian media

What the evidence says about sugar

Cutting back on added sugar is one of the most widely supported pieces of nutrition advice. In 2015 the World Health Organization recommended that adults and children keep "free sugars" below 10% of their daily energy intake, and suggested that going below 5%, about 25 grams or six teaspoons a day, brings further benefits.

Free sugars are the ones added to food and drink by manufacturers, cooks or ourselves, plus the sugars found in honey, syrups and fruit juice. The sugar naturally present in whole fruit, vegetables and milk does not count. WHO links high intake of free sugars mainly to weight gain and tooth decay, and it treats lowering intake as part of the wider fight against conditions such as type 2 diabetes and heart disease.

70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

What about looks? Researchers have studied how high blood sugar can damage collagen through a process called glycation, which may play a part in skin ageing. That is a reasonable reason to think a low-sugar diet does skin no harm. But no good study shows that quitting sugar alone takes decades off someone's appearance. Genes, sun exposure, smoking, sleep, stress, weight changes and skincare all play big roles, and Hartz herself credits a combination of habits.

The doubters, and why they matter

Not everyone was convinced. When the photos spread, plenty of commenters suspected cosmetic procedures, flattering professional photography, or simply very good genes. Others pointed out that she sells a sugar substitute, so her story also works as publicity for her business. Hartz has credited her lifestyle, and there is no public evidence either way about procedures.

Both things can be true at once. Her habits are sensible and backed by mainstream advice, and her appearance is also the product of factors many people cannot copy, from genetics to the time and money to care for themselves. The healthiest way to read her story is as encouragement, not as a standard to measure yourself against. That is, in fact, how she frames it too: she has said she wants people to be inspired by others without comparing themselves negatively, because envy and self-criticism only damage wellbeing.

70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

A note on sugar substitutes

If you follow Hartz's lead and swap sugar for xylitol, a few facts are worth knowing. Xylitol is a sugar alcohol found in small amounts in some fruits and vegetables. It is about as sweet as table sugar but has roughly 40% fewer calories and only a small effect on blood glucose.

It has two well-known drawbacks. In larger amounts it can upset the stomach and act as a laxative, so it is best introduced slowly. And it is highly toxic to dogs, even in small doses, so baking made with it should be kept well away from pets. If you have diabetes or another medical condition, talk to a doctor before making big changes to your diet.

How to cut back without going cold turkey

Few people will match Hartz's 28 years without added sugar, and you do not need to. Gradual changes are easier to keep:

  • Start with drinks. Soft drinks, sweetened coffees and juices are among the biggest sources of free sugar for many people.
  • Shrink portions before you cut foods out. Have a smaller slice of your favourite dessert while you look for lower-sugar alternatives you enjoy.
  • Read labels. Sugar hides in sauces, breakfast cereals, flavoured yoghurts and even some supplements.
  • Build meals around protein and fibre. As Hartz found, they help keep cravings in check.
  • Look after the basics. Poor sleep and stress both make sweet foods more tempting.
70-Year-Old Woman Says Going Sugar-Free 28 Years Ago Keeps Her Young

Carolyn Hartz's own closing advice was less about food than about outlook: celebrate other people's successes, let go of jealousy, and stop worrying about your age. Whatever the exact reason for her youthful looks, that is advice almost anyone can follow.

Sources: Photos courtesy of Carolyn Hartz / SweetLife, as published by Australian media. Oddity Central: 70-year-old woman credits youthful looks on sugar-free diet; Bored Panda: reaction to Carolyn Hartz's story; Powerful Mind; World Health Organization: guideline on sugars intake (2015); CDC: Prediabetes; Wikipedia: Xylitol.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 2