First published November 2, 2016.
A relationship is not a predictable body change
An association between coffee intake and breast volume does not show that changing the amount someone drinks will produce a predictable physical change. The result concerned a defined study group and a genetic variant, rather than a universal response to coffee.

The relationship between coffee intake and breast volume attracted attention because it sounded like a simple everyday cause with a visible effect. The study asked a narrower research question, involving reported intake, measured volume and genetic variation.
Swedish researchers reported an association between coffee intake, a genetic variant and breast volume.(Daily Mail coverage) The researchers examined the association in the context of questions about breast cancer risk; that research context is different from demonstrating a preventive effect.
The chief oncologist of the study, Helena Jernstroem, was observing data linking large-breasted women to an increased risk of a breast cancer diagnosis, when she found the link between coffee and breasts. The breast-volume finding does not establish that three daily cups reduce an individual woman’s cancer risk.
The study discussed variation in CYP1A2 and an association that differed between groups. It did not identify a gene that reliably causes coffee-related breast shrinkage.
Jernstroem assured us, “They will get smaller but the breasts aren’t just going to disappear.”
Though she did add, “Anyone who thinks they can tell which women are coffee drinkers just from their bra measurements will be disappointed.” Adding, “The problem is that there are two measures for a bra — the cup size and the girth, so you wouldn’t be able to tell.”
Body size is not a reason to assign blame to a favourite drink, and the findings do not turn bra measurements into a record of coffee consumption. The distinction matters because an entertaining headline can make an observational result sound much more personal and predictable than the study supports.
By Alex Alexander
Source: YourTango via Ideaspots
Additional source: British Journal of Cancer: coffee intake, CYP1A2 and breast volume.
The study examined an association in a defined group
The 2008 paper related coffee intake to breast volume and a CYP1A2 genetic variant in premenopausal women. Its reported association differed by genotype; it was not a trial demonstrating that drinking coffee shrinks someone’s breasts. Breast volume and the occurrence of breast cancer are also different outcomes. Keeping those distinctions clear allows the research question to remain interesting without converting it into a cosmetic promise or a recommendation for cancer prevention.

The best joke ever. Looks like every crap, wrapped in "science says", have a huge impact to the customers nowadays
ReplyDeleteThe best joke ever. Looks like every crap, wrapped in "science says", have a huge impact to the customers nowadays
ReplyDeleteIf Science drink Coffee, Makes their brain smaller
ReplyDeleteWell then, I guess it is a diet drink and can help you "lose weight" like green tea. This should be great news for lots of women. Besides it can also help with the goal of a "gender neutral" world, which is what progressives and liberals have been telling us is the "correct" way.😎
ReplyDelete